What to Wear, What to Skip, and the Makeup That Actually Works
For decades, the redhead was handed rules like heirlooms.
Never wear red.
Avoid pink.
Stick to neutrals.
So we asked a group of redheads what actually works—and what they’ve learned to ignore.
The responses were thoughtful, specific, and surprisingly consistent. If you have copper strands, freckles, or porcelain skin in your life (your own or someone you love), here’s what real women say makes the difference.
Some of the links in this post are affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. Every product mentioned here was recommended by the redheads who shared their tips with us.
The Biggest Myth: “A Redhead Can’t Wear Red”
More than one woman said she had grown up hearing this rule. However, just as many admitted they now happily ignore it.
“I always believed I couldn’t wear red,” one told us. “But I get compliments every time I do now.”
However, the common thread wasn’t avoiding color; it was choosing the right undertone.
Redheads reported feeling strongest in:
- Jewel tones (emerald, sapphire, plum)
- Cool-toned reds
- Deep berry shades
- Teal and rose
- Cream and ivory instead of stark white
For example, several specifically mentioned plum as a consistent compliment-getter.
The takeaway? It isn’t the color. It’s the temperature.
Undertones Matter More Than Hair Color
In fact, a surprising pattern emerged: many assumed red hair meant warm skin. Several discovered the opposite.
Cool undertones were common—which meant:
- Rose-based foundation tones
- Pink blush instead of peach
- Taupe eyeshadow instead of bronze
- Pink-brown or mauve lips
One said switching to rose undertones changed everything.
Another said she swears by taupe palettes and pink-chocolate combinations for eyes.
And more than one redhead told us she prefers cream over bright white—softer, more harmonious, less stark against pale skin.
Freckles, Sensitive Skin, and Letting Skin Look Like Skin
In addition, sensitive skin came up repeatedly.
Full-coverage foundation often flattens freckles or feels heavy. Several women skip foundation entirely in favor of tinted moisturizer or mineral formulas.
One mentioned Bare Minerals as a longtime match for sensitive skin. Another recommended How to Be a Redhead for products specifically geared toward redheads.
The general philosophy?
Let freckles show.
Light coverage.
Skin that looks like skin.
The Redhead Makeup Shortlist
Here are the products mentioned most often:
Blush & Cheek
- NARS “Orgasm” blush (a cult favorite for good reason)
- Seint Lip + Cheek in Hollywood
- NARS The Multiple in “Orgasm”
Eyes
Lips
Across the board: pink, plum, chocolate, taupe—soft warmth with a cool base.
What to Skip as a Redhead (If It’s Not Working)
While everyone is different, patterns emerged:
- Stark white (cream is kinder)
- Orange-based bronzers
- Very bright, hard neons
- Heavy foundation
And perhaps most important:
“Wear what you like.”
More than one woman echoed that sentiment. Confidence reads louder than color theory.
The Real Lesson
In the end, what stood out most wasn’t a lipstick shade or a sweater color.
It was the quiet shift from rules to calibration.
From “never wear red” to “find your red.”
From assuming warm undertones to discovering cool harmony.
And finally, from covering freckles to celebrating them.
Red hair may be rare, but it isn’t fragile. It doesn’t need protection from color—it needs partnership with it.
And according to the women who live in it every day, jewel tones, rose undertones, and a little plum go a long way.
+ Leave a comment
back to pretty